On October 5, a two-bedroom house on Carmet Drive closed for $1.3 million. It was built in 1953 and has 1,148 square feet, which works out to $1,132 a square foot. Three weeks later, on October 26, a four-bedroom house on Ranch Road closed for $1.33 million. That house was built in 2009 and has 3,138 square feet, a pool and half an acre, which works out to $424 a square foot.
The two prices are $30,000 apart, and one house is nearly three times the size of the other. Around Bodega Bay, most of the price comes from the address, and extra square footage adds far less than an inland buyer would expect. The address also decides where the water comes from, and this stretch of coast draws on four separate water systems.
Seven Fall Closings, Sorted by Price per Square Foot
The Press Democrat publishes public-record roundups of local home sales. Between late September and late October 2026, it reported these seven "Bodega Bay" closings.
| Street | Closed | Price | Sq ft | Built | Per sq ft |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Carmet Drive | Oct. 5 | $1,300,000 | 1,148 | 1953 | $1,132 |
| Las Flores | Oct. 13 | $995,000 | 1,004 | 1983 | $991 |
| Oyster Catcher Loop | Oct. 7 | $2,400,000 | 2,837 | 1981 | $846 |
| Los Santos Drive | Sept. 25 | $995,000 | 1,350 | 1970 | $737 |
| Heron Drive | Oct. 19 | $1,580,000 | 2,214 | 1987 | $714 |
| Bay View Street | Oct. 2 | $600,000 | 1,086 | 1971 | $552 |
| Ranch Road | Oct. 26 | $1,330,000 | 3,138 | 2009 | $424 |
The Press Democrat's roundup of five sales with titles recorded between October 12 and November 1 put the average at $1.38 million and $847 a square foot. That average is accurate. It also blends a 1953 cottage, a 1981 house of nearly 2,900 square feet and a 1971 two-bedroom into one figure that describes none of them.
Look at the middle of the table. Four of the seven homes closed between $995,000 and $1.33 million, and those four houses ranged from 1,004 to 3,138 square feet. Inland, a spread in size that large usually means a large spread in price. Here, the size of the house moved the price by less than the gap between the cheapest and the most expensive sale in the group.
The Smallest Houses Drew the Highest Prices per Foot
The two homes at the top of the table are both two-bedroom houses with less than 1,200 square feet. One of them is the oldest house on the list. Buyers paid close to or above $1,000 a square foot for them.
Price per square foot falls as a house gets bigger in most markets, because a buyer pays for the land once no matter how many rooms sit on it. On the Sonoma Coast the effect is unusually steep. A buyer who wants a particular street, setting or distance to the water pays most of the price just to own a house there. Every square foot after that adds comparatively little.
Acreage didn't reverse the pattern this fall. The house on Los Santos Drive sits on 0.9 acres and closed at $737 a square foot. The house on Ranch Road has half an acre and a pool and closed at $424. In January, a larger house elsewhere on Los Santos Drive closed at $613 a square foot on 2,325 square feet. On the same street, the bigger house drew the lower price per foot.
The "Bodega Bay" label on these roundups also covers more than one kind of community. Heron Drive is inside Bodega Harbour, the golf community whose homeowners association holds its own events and awards. Other addresses on the list have half-acre and larger lots. If you're comparing a listing against "Bodega Bay comps," find out which of those comps share its kind of street, lot and setting before you treat any of them as a benchmark.
The Coast Sells Slower and Higher Than the County
The countywide numbers explain why a portal's median gives you so little to go on here. In October 2026, BAREIS counted 405 closed residential sales across Sonoma County, with a $755,000 median sold price and a 39-day median time on market. In the same month, BAREIS's Coastal Sonoma area recorded 10 sales, a $1.57 million average price and an average of 75 days on market. The county figure is a median and the coastal figure is an average, so the gap between 39 and 75 days isn't an exact comparison. Ten sales is also a thin month for any market. Even so, coastal homes in October sold at about double the county price and took longer to sell.
The California Association of Realtors reported a $875,000 median for existing single-family homes in Sonoma County in September 2026, with 4.0 months of unsold inventory. Several of the Bodega Bay homes in the table closed above that county median despite having less floor space than a typical suburban house.
Per-foot pricing on the coast has held up. From the week of January 27 to the week of April 5, 2025, the Press Democrat counted nine Bodega Bay-area sales averaging $805 a square foot. The five sales with titles recorded from mid-October to the start of November 2026 averaged $847. Both are small samples, so they show a market holding its level. They don't prove a trend.
Four Water Systems Under One Place Name
If the address carries most of the price, it helps to know what else comes with it. A home within a few miles of Bodega Bay can draw its water from any of four systems, and each one is a different size and taps different sources.
Bodega Bay Public Utility District runs seven wells, more than 21 miles of water mains and 1,160 water connections. One of its wells sits next to Salmon Creek, and other wells can supply the system when that well is curtailed. The district also handles wastewater. It treats sewage, runs eight lift stations and reuses treated wastewater to irrigate the Bodega Harbour golf course and district land. For July 2026 through June 2027, the district's sewer rate ordinance lists a fixed single-family sewer charge of $141.47 per two-month billing period. On top of that is a $30.31 surcharge per billing period for the 2022 Sewer Rehabilitation Project. This is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice, so confirm what a specific property pays with the district and your own advisors. The district's October 21, 2026 board agenda included ongoing emergency tank repairs and accepting the lining work on the North Town Redwood Tank.
Salmon Creek gets its water from a County Service Area system that Russian River Utility runs. According to RRU, the system has 99 customers and draws from a shallow well and a spring gallery.
Sereno del Mar Water Company is owned by Russian River Utility. It dates to 1970, when the Sereno del Mar subdivisions were laid out, and it serves 139 customers. Its treatment plant is a microfiltration membrane facility that was completed in 2001.
Carmet-by-the-Sea Mutual Water Company is a nonprofit next door. It draws from two hillside wells and is connected to Sereno del Mar's 300,000-gallon storage tanks, so its customers receive filtered water through the shared plant. The two companies are managed separately.
These systems run from a district with 1,160 connections down to a 99-customer system fed by a well and a spring. Two homes with the same price per square foot can depend on very different water setups, and that is one more way two "Bodega Bay" comps can describe different products.
Before You Compare Two Listings
Start with the parcel. Russian River Utility says it will check connection eligibility for a specific address and parcel within about a week. Ask early on which system serves the home or lot and what that system currently charges.
Then match the comps to the product. A 1,100-square-foot cottage that closed above $1,000 a foot isn't a fair benchmark for a 3,000-square-foot house on half an acre, and a Bodega Harbour golf-course home isn't either, even when all three carry the same "Bodega Bay" label. Compare the Carmet Drive cottage with other small, older houses, and compare the Ranch Road house with other large homes on big lots.
If you're weighing two Bodega Bay addresses and want help working out which comps fit each one and which water system serves it, Kristopher Lepore can go through both with you before you write an offer. Browse current Bodega Bay homes for sale, and when you're ready, Let's Connect.